We feature items we believe will benefit our audience. If you purchase through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s how we do it.
You’re at your best friend’s beach wedding, looking absolutely fabulous in your flowy sundress when suddenly the waterworks start. No, not because of the beautiful vows—although those were tear-jerkers too—but because a rogue wave decided to crash the party and soak you from head to toe. As you’re laughing and wringing out your dress, you realize your mascara hasn’t budged an inch. That is the magic of the best drugstore waterproof mascara.
Now, I know what you’re thinking. “Waterproof mascara? Isn’t that stuff impossible to remove?” Trust me, I’ve been there. After using a high-end waterproof mascara, I once had to scrub my eyes so hard that I looked like a raccoon for days. But here’s the kicker—you don’t need to spend a fortune or sacrifice your lashes to get that bulletproof look. The best drugstore waterproof mascara options out there are total game-changers.
So, buckle up to find your, cry-proof, splash-proof, life-proof mascaras that’ll make your lashes look like a million bucks—without spending nearly that much.
In This Article
Importance of Waterproof Mascara
Let’s talk about why waterproof mascara is basically the lifesaver of the makeup world. Whether you’re ugly-crying through a rom-com, sweating it out at the gym, or just dealing with your eyes watering from seasonal allergies (hello, pollen!), waterproof mascara has got your back. It’s the ride-or-die friend that sticks with you through thick and thin, come rain or shine—literally.
Benefits of Choosing Drugstore Options
But why go drugstore, you ask? Well, let me count the ways!
Budget-Friendly: First off, your wallet will thank you. We’re talking mascara so good, you’ll forget it didn’t cost you half your paycheck.
Quality That Competes: Drugstore brands have seriously upped their game in recent years. They’re packing their formulas with nourishing ingredients, innovating with amazing brush designs, and delivering results that’ll make you do a double-take in the mirror.
Fresh Lashes, Always: And let’s be real—how many times have you fallen in love with a mascara only to have it dry out before you could say “holy grail”? With the best drugstore waterproof mascara options, you can afford to replace them regularly, ensuring you always have fresh, clump-free lashes. It’s like having your cake and eating it too, but for your eyelashes.
How We Picked Our Lash Game-Changers
Let’s talk about how we narrowed down the vast world of best drugstore waterproof mascara options to our top picks. Spoiler alert: It involved a lot of batting eyelashes and some very scientific “cry tests.”
The Method to Our Mascara Madness
When it comes to choosing the crème de la crème of affordable lash enhancers, we didn’t mess around. Here’s what we looked for:
- Performance: Because nobody wants raccoon eyes halfway through their day
- Price: We’re talking drugstore, so it better not break the bank
- Ingredients: Lash-loving formulas only, please and thank you
- Staying Power: If it can’t survive a Nicholas Sparks movie marathon, it’s out
- Brush Design: From curved to straight, we tried ’em all
- User Reviews: Real talk from real people? Yes, please!
Our (Not So) Scientific Testing Process
Now, for the fun part – how we put these best drugstore waterproof mascara contenders through their paces. Let’s just say, it was an adventure.
The Great Mascara Olympics
- The Shower Test: Because sometimes you remember you’re still wearing makeup mid-shampoo
- The Tearjerker Challenge: Cue the sad puppy videos
- The Workout Warrior: Sweating buckets at hot yoga? No problem
- The All-Day Wear: From 9 to 5 and beyond
The Nitty-Gritty Details
But wait, there’s more! We didn’t just slap on some mascara and call it a day. Oh no, we got down to the nitty-gritty:
- Application ease (because who has time for a 10-step lash routine?)
- Clump factor (ain’t nobody got time for spider lashes)
- Flake check (black specks on your cheeks are so last season)
- Removal process (if it requires industrial-strength solvent, it’s a no from us)
After weeks of testing (and some very dramatic eyelash fluttering), we narrowed it down to our top picks. These best drugstore waterproof mascara winners survived tears, sweat, and the occasional accidental nap with makeup on (we’ve all been there).
The Fabulous Dozen: Our Top Best Drugstore Waterproof Mascara Picks
Alright, it’s time for the main event! We’ve scoured the drugstore aisles to bring you the crème de la crème of affordable, waterproof lash enhancers. Drum roll, please!
1. L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara: The Crowd-Pleaser
What’s the Buzz?
- Soft wavy brush for intense volume
- Over 200 bristles to catch every lash
- Silky smooth formula for clump-free application
Why We’re Obsessed
This little pink tube is like the Ryan Gosling of mascaras – it does it all, and it does it well. It’s got volume, length, and staying power that’ll make you wonder if it’s actually a permanent marker for your lashes (spoiler: it’s not, but it’s close!).
2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara: The Lash Multiplier
The Deets
- Unique fanning brush with ten layers of bristles
- Liquid ink formula for intense black lashes
- Ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes
Our Love Letter
If your lashes could write a thank-you note, they’d send one to Maybelline. This mascara doesn’t just coat your lashes; it practically creates new ones out of thin air. Magic? Maybe. Awesome? Definitely.
3. CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara: The OG Volume Queen
What’s Inside
- Large plastic brush for maximum product deposit
- Hypoallergenic formula
- Smudge and smear-proof all day long
Why It’s a Keeper
This orange tube has been a staple in makeup bags for years, and for good reason. It’s like the reliable friend of the best drugstore waterproof mascara world – always there when you need it, never letting you down.
4. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Waterproof Mascara: The Budget Bae
The Lowdown
- Conic fibre brush for precise application
- Intense black colour for dramatic effect
- Cruelty-free and budget-friendly
Our Crush Explained
If this mascara were a person, it’d be the one that makes you wonder, “How are you still single?” It’s gorgeous, reliable, and doesn’t cost an arm and a leg. What’s not to love?
5. Revlon Volumazing Waterproof Mascara: The Conditioning Queen
Standout Features
- Conditioning formula with carnauba wax and olive oil
- Triple grooved brush for maximum volume
- Clump-free and flake-free wear
Why We Can’t Get Enough
This mascara is like a spa day for your lashes. It pampers, it volumizes, and it sticks around longer than your last Netflix binge. Talk about commitment!
6. NYX Professional Makeup Worth the Hype Waterproof Mascara: The Cool Kid
What’s Hot
- Buildable formula for customizable lash looks
- Tapered brush for easy application
- Vegan and cruelty-free
Our Hype is Real
This mascara lives up to its name and then some. It’s like the effortlessly cool friend who always knows the best underground bands – but for your lashes.
7. Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Mascara: The Drama Queen
The Scoop
- Extreme volume and length in one coat
- Unique max-density brush
- Intense black pigments for bold lashes
Why We’re Scandalously in Love
If your lashes could star in a soap opera, this would be their go-to mascara. It brings the drama, the volume, and the staying power – all without the diva attitude.
8. e.l.f. Lash It Loud Waterproof Mascara: The Loud and Proud Lash Enhancer
Key Points
- Oversized brush for maximum volume and length
- Waterproof formula that lasts all-day
- 100% vegan and cruelty-free
Our Elf-sized Obsession
Talk about a mascara that lives up to its name! This mascara isn’t just whispering sweet nothings to your lashes – it’s shouting from the rooftops! It’s like your lashes just got their own megaphone. It gives you bold, dramatic lashes that refuse to be ignored, all while keeping your wallet happy.
9. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Plumping Waterproof Mascara: The Lash Hydrator
The 411
- Hyaluronic acid-infused formula for lash hydration
- Clump-free and flake-free wear
- Ophthalmologist tested
Why We’re Hooked
This mascara is like a tall glass of water for your parched lashes. It plumps, it hydrates, and it sticks around longer than your last New Year’s resolution.
10. Wet n Wild Mega Length Waterproof Mascara: The Bargain Bestie
What’s Inside
- Vitamin E enriched formula
- Slim brush for precise application
- Ultra-affordable price point
Our Wallet Thanks Us
This mascara proves that sometimes, the best things in life (or at least in your makeup bag) are nearly free. It’s the overachiever of the best drugstore waterproof mascara world – doing the most while asking for the least.
11. No7 Stay Perfect Waterproof Long-Wear Tubular Mascara: The Innovator
The Deets
- Unique tubular technology for easy removal
- Smudge-proof and flake-proof formula
- Hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive eyes
Why We’re Tube-ular Fans
This mascara is like the science nerd of the bunch – it’s got all these cool innovations that make you go “Why didn’t anyone think of this before?” Plus, it comes off with just warm water. Mind. Blown.
12. Maybelline New York The Falsies Lash Lift Waterproof Mascara: The Faux Lash Faker
Standout Features
- Double-curved lifting brush for a false lash effect
- Fiber-infused formula for added length and volume
- Long-lasting waterproof wear
Our Glam Obsession
Move over, lash extensions! This mascara is here to give you that coveted falsies look without the salon price tag or the hassle. It’s like your lashes just hit the gym and got a major lift!
Finding Your Perfect Lash Match
Picking the perfect mascara can feel like trying to find a needle in a haystack… if that haystack was filled with tiny tubes of lash-enhancing goodness. But don’t worry, I’ve got your back! Let’s break down how to find your holy grail best drugstore waterproof mascara.
What Do Your Lashes Need? (Besides a hug)
The Volume Seekers
- Look for words like “volumizing” or “plumping” on the tube
- Opt for mascaras with thicker, creamier formulas
- Big, fluffy brushes are your BFFs
If your lashes are feeling a bit, well, meh, a volumizing waterproof mascara might be just what the doctor ordered. Think of it as a push-up bra for your lashes!
The Length Lovers
- Keep an eye out for “lengthening” or “extending” in the product name
- Choose mascaras with fibre-rich formulas
- Slim, straight brushes are great for reaching those tiny lashes
Want lashes so long they could be classified as a new species? A lengthening formula is your ticket to Lash City, population: you!
The Curl Crusaders
- “Curling” or “lifting” are your magic words
- Look for formulas that promise to hold a curl
- Curved brushes can help lift those stubborn straight lashes
If your lashes are straighter than your 7th-grade ruler, a curling waterproof mascara can be a game-changer. It’s like a perm for your lashes, minus the 80s vibes.
Brush Up on Your Brush Knowledge
The Plastic Fantastic
- Separates and defines lashes like a dream
- Great for precise application
- Often found in lengthening formulas
The Bristle Bustle
- Deposits more product for volume
- Can create a more dramatic look
- Often found in volumizing formulas
The Comb Crew
- Helps separate lashes and prevent clumps
- Great for those with naturally thick lashes
- Often found in defining formulas
Remember, the brush can make or break your lash game. It’s like finding the right magic wand – when you find the one, you’ll know!
Bonus Round: Extra Lash Love
The Conditioner Contenders
- Look for ingredients like vitamin E, argan oil, or keratin
- Great for those with dry or brittle lashes
- Can help improve lash health over time
Think of these as a green smoothie for your lashes. They’re not just pretty, they’re nutritious too!
The Sensitive Souls
- Keep an eye out for “hypoallergenic” or “ophthalmologist-tested”
- Often fragrance-free and suitable for contact lens wearers
- Perfect for those with easily irritated eyes
Because nobody wants their best drugstore waterproof mascara to turn them into a weepy mess (unless you’re watching “The Notebook”, then all bets are off).
The Quick-Change Artists
- Look for “easy removal” or “wash-off” in the product name
- Often use tubing technology for easy removal
- Great for those who hate scrubbing their eyes at night
These are like the Cinderella of mascaras – fabulous all day, but ready to disappear when the clock strikes bedtime.
Application and Removal 101
You’ve found your best drugstore waterproof mascara, but now what? Don’t worry, I’ve got you covered with some pro tips on how to apply and remove these stubborn beauties. Let’s dive in!
Putting Your Best Lash Forward: Application Techniques
The Wiggle and Sweep
- Start at the base of your lashes
- Wiggle the wand back and forth as you sweep upwards
- This deposits more product at the roots for a fuller look
The Layering Game
- Apply one coat and let it dry for 30 seconds
- Go in with a second coat for added drama
- Don’t wait too long between coats, or you risk clumping
The Lash Comb Savior
- Apply your mascara as usual
- Use a lash comb to separate any clumps
- This also helps distribute the product evenly
Tip: The Tissue Trick! Want to avoid those pesky mascara marks on your eyelids? Here’s a neat trick; Hold a tissue over your eyelid while applying mascara. This catches any excess product and helps you get super close to the lash line!
Removing Your Waterproof Mascara
The Double Cleanse Method
- Start with an oil-based cleanser or makeup remover
- Follow up with your regular face wash or foaming cleanser
- Gently does it – no need to scrub like you’re cleaning grout!
This two-step process is like a spa day for your lashes. Your best drugstore waterproof mascara might be stubborn, but it’s no match for this dynamic duo!
The Soak and Slide
- Soak a cotton pad in eye makeup remover
- Press it against your closed eye for 30 seconds
- Gently wipe away – the mascara should slide right off
It’s like giving your mascara a nice warm bath before saying goodbye. Spa day for your lashes, part two!
The Micellar Magic
- Use a micellar water specifically designed for waterproof makeup
- Apply to a cotton pad and hold it against your lashes
- Wipe gently – no rubbing needed!
Micellar water is like the Swiss Army knife of skincare – it does it all, and it does it well!
Products That Play Nice with Waterproof Mascara
- Bi-phase makeup removers (the ones you need to shake)
- Cleansing balms (they melt away makeup like butter)
- Gentle baby oil (yes, really!)
Remember, your best drugstore waterproof mascara is like that friend who’s always the last to leave the party. Sometimes you need to give them a little extra encouragement to head home!
Tip: The Overnight Oil Treatment – If you’re really struggling with removal, try this;Apply a bit of coconut or olive oil to your lashes before bed. Let it work its magic overnight. Wash off in the morning for effortlessly clean lashes
Final Thoughts
We’ve been on quite the roller coaster ride, haven’t we? From diving into the depths of drugstore aisles to battling clumps and flakes, we’ve seen it all. And you know what? I’m here to tell you that the perfect lash look doesn’t have to cost you an arm, a leg, and your firstborn child.
These best drugstore waterproof mascara options we’ve explored are like that reliable friend who’s always there for you – through tears, sweat, and impromptu pool parties. They’ve got your back (or should I say your lashes) when you need them most.
Remember, finding your holy grail mascara is a bit like dating. Sometimes you need to kiss a few frogs before you find your prince. But trust me, when you find “the one,” you’ll know. Your lashes will sing, your eyes will pop, and you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it.
So whether you’re Team Volume, a Length Lover, or a Curl Connoisseur, there’s the best drugstore waterproof mascara out there with your name on it. And the best part? You can experiment to your heart’s content without breaking the bank. It’s like an all-you-can-eat buffet for your lashes!
Leave a Reply